New Report Reiterates Kids First Stance
High-quality child care can have a lasting impact on a child’s development, behavior and cognitive abilities, according to a report released Monday by the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development (NICHD). The report echoes the position long held by the City of Aspen’s childcare program, Kids First. 

Based on the findings of the report, children who received high-quality care in the first few years of life scored higher on measures of academic and cognitive achievement when they were 15 years old. They also were less likely to misbehave than those who were enrolled in lower-quality child care, according to the report. 

“The report clearly shows that high-quality child care is related to future academic success,” said Linda K. Smith, executive director of the National Association of Child Care Resource & Referral Agencies (NACCRRA). “Yet, most children do not have access to quality care. We’ve had 40 years of child care research, all with a consistent message – quality child care makes a difference. The NICHD study shows that even 10 years after children have left child care, quality child care is still related to higher academic achievement. But, the condition of child care throughout the country is poor. Standards are weak; oversight is weaker.”

Colorado ranked 41st in the nation, with 72 out of 150 points scored in regulation and oversight of childcare centers. Four recommendations were not met at all, and five were partially met, out of 15 total recommendations. For licensed childcare homes, Colorado ranked 9th in the nation with 78 out of 140 points. No state got higher than 110 points; nine states got 0 points. So ranking 9th indicates that Colorado scored high among states, but did not necessarily get a high score.

“What is important about today’s report is that it shows the quality of care can have a long-lasting  impact on middle class and affluent children, not poor children alone,” said Shirley Ritter, director of Kids First. “I hope this report is a wake-up call to Congress. The primary reason that state child care policies are so weak is that the Child Care and Development Block Grant (CCDBG), the law that gives guidance to states in setting state child care policy, needs to be strengthened.”

Today, more than 11 million children nationally under age 5 are in some type of child care setting every week while their parents work. On average, children of working mothers spend 36 hours every week in child care.  In Colorado, it is estimated that over 210,000 children (2009 Kids Count) are cared for in licensed childcare.

To improve the quality of care, NACCRRA recommends that Congress: (1) require all child care providers regularly paid to care for unrelated children to be licensed and routinely inspected; (2) require all paid providers to undergo a comprehensive background check based on fingerprints; (3) require an inspection/site visit prior to licensing and at least one inspection annually; (4) require 40 or more hours of initial training and 24 hours of annual training (in basic areas like CPR, first aid, safe sleeping practices for infants, child development, etc.); (5) require states to meet each of the 10 basic health and safety standards pediatricians and child development experts recommend; (6) grant the Child Care Bureau the authority to assess state child care plans for content and compliance and withhold funds from states with insufficient policies and oversight; (7) require states to justify any categories of providers who are exempt from regulation and (8) require states to post inspection results on the Internet.

Colorado does some of these things, but it is not universal, nor is it funded at the national level.

The City of Aspen has funded childcare programs, quality improvement, financial aid and more through Kids First since 1992.

“We are privileged to have local funding to help children and families,” said Ritter. “But there needs to be a federal standard that at least insures that children are safe and have early success if we want the next generation to be productive in our nation.”

NACCRRA has released two reports about the condition of child care throughout the United States: We Can Do Better, which scores and ranks the states based on state child care center policies and Leaving Children to Chance, which scores and ranks the states based on state small family child care home policies.  To download a copy of these reports or learn more about NACCRRA, visit  The full report from NICHD and more current news can be found at

Posted on Tuesday, May 18, 2010